- KindnessisPunk@piefed.caEnglish24 days
Our justice system has gone full mask off, it exist to protect capital. There needs to be serious reform to protect the people with consequences for corporatists.
CileTheSane@lemmy.caEnglish
24 daysThe legal system has determined money is speech, which means their voices are a hell of a lot louder than yours.
- jaycifer@lemmy.worldEnglish24 days
Capital lobbyists already have so much sway over the government in the US, I think we should go full corporatist and build national level unions to counter their interests.
- lost_faith@lemmy.caEnglish24 days
So, that means YOU will delete everything YOU scraped for LLM training and start over by ASKING and PAYING first?
Nik282000@lemmy.caEnglish
24 daysAbout 1/3 of my bot hits have been from MS hosting since the summer. Fuck 'em. 30 years is enough.
- supersquirrel@lemmy.caEnglish24 days
Microslop and Epic are acting like characters out of Fawlty Towers.
- ThrowawayOnLemmy@lemmy.worldEnglish24 days
The theft will continue regardless of what the courts say. We’re just following your example, Microsoft.
- 24 days
Well you can eat it, but then you won’t have it anymore.
- DebatableRaccoon@lemmy.caEnglish24 days
That’s because it’s okay when he rips off other people’s work. Ya gotta keep up, my dude.
atopi@piefed.blahaj.zoneEnglish
23 daysThis feels funny considering that minecraft (java edition) recently (a year ago) became source available (as far as i know)
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysThat’s not what has happened. Microsoft and Epic don’t want their IP used without they have been paid. They do not agree that training on Ai is theft, they agree on using their IP publicly without their consent is theft.
Riskable@programming.devEnglish
24 daysCorrection: They think distributing their IP without permission is a violation of their copyrights (which is true).
“Theft” is not a thing when it comes to copyright. Every time someone uses “theft” to describe copyright infringement, the MPAA, RIAA, Microsoft, EPIC, Sony, and Disney all have a little orgasm and layoff another worker that created that IP.
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysThat’s splitting the hairs. If someone uses an IP without permission, then it is theft.
- Laser@feddit.orgEnglish24 days
So the training of their AI on content without permission was theft? Last year, they argued the opposite.
Jokes aside, copyright infringement or license violatipns aren’t theft.
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysSo the training of their AI on content without permission was theft?
yes.
Last year, they argued the opposite.
Doesn’t matter what they said last year.
Jokes aside, copyright infringement or license violatipns aren’t theft.
It is.
🇰 🌀 🇱 🇦 🇳 🇦 🇰 🇮 @pawb.socialEnglish
24 daysTheft noun
the felonious taking and removing of personal property with intent to deprive the rightful owner of it
Making a copy does not deprive anyone of their property. Therefore it is not theft. That’s why it’s called a “copyright violation” and isn’t treated the same as theft under the law.
- Ekkosangen@lemmy.caEnglish24 days
Just want to give you kudos on some fine trolling, you really got a good few people going for a bit.
Riskable@programming.devEnglish
24 daysListen: Theft is a legal term, just like copyright. When someone steals something (theft), the owner of that thing doesn’t have it anymore. When someone violates copyright the owner still has the thing and can continue to make as many copies of it as they like.
In the 80s, 90s, and 2000s the RIAA and MPAA had vast marketing campaigns trying to re-brand copyright violation as “theft”. Copyright existed for centuries before Congress decided to pass The Sound Recording Act of 1971 and the Copyright Act of 1976 which was the first time (ever) that copying something without permission could be prosecuted as a criminal offense (instead of civil).
The “Piracy is Theft” thing is literally from one of their advertising campaigns! They invented it and it’s nothing but pro-corporate propaganda. Do not think for one second that anyone stands to lose significant amounts of money from piracy other than corporations and even that’s debatable.
Piracy is almost always a service problem and not a pricing problem. -Gabe Newell, founder of Valve Software (Steam)
Individuals have been copying stuff since forever and nobody cared until some bean counter invented the disproven concept of “one pirated thing == one lost sale.” We all know that’s not how it works! That entire concept is another form of “Hollywood Accounting”:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
So no. Fuck no. It’s not “splitting hairs.”
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysIf you steal an art and use it in ways you have no rights to, then it is theft.
Riskable@programming.devEnglish
24 daysYeah, if I physically stole the artwork, then yes? That’s stealing. Let’s cover all the bases, though, shall we?
If I took a picture of some art, is that stealing? No. That’s not illegal anywhere.
If I then shared that picture with a friend? No. That doesn’t count as a “public performance” or “public display” of the work.
If I then shared that picture with the Internet at large? Yes, that’s copyright infringement—every time someone downloaded it, that counts as one violation. Specifically, derivative copyright infringement (which is a whole world of law in itself).
Aside: The RIAA argued in court that merely placing one of their copyrighted movies/songs on the Internet counted as distributing their work to the entire world’s (Internet) population and therefore, the defendant should be held liable for billions of copyright violations for each work they merely made available (who cares about the actual number of downloads, right? LOL). THEY ASKED FOR $72 TRILLION IN DAMAGES:
Saying “piracy is theft” is playing right into their hands. Unless you’re a paid corporate shill/bot, you shouldn’t be making arguments on their behalf. At this point you should be asking yourself, “Are we the baddies?”
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysI’m talking about stealing the IP by using a copy or using the IP in any way. Not necessarily physical object. Your examples doesn’t make sense, because I said if you use it in ways you have no rights. You listed examples where the user has the rights to (the ones with photo).
I am also not talking about piracy. That’s way broader and different topic.
Riskable@programming.devEnglish
24 daysI have no idea what you’re even talking about. The only way possible to “steal IP” is to break into someone’s office/home/whatever and physically take it away. The only copy of that thing that exists.
- jorpy laforge@lemmy.worldEnglish24 days
You know your argument is so weak that you feel you can’t make it without redefining a centuries old term.
- Zorque@lemmy.worldEnglish24 days
It can be. But if thats the only thing that has value, it is not art.
- 24 days
Man, you’re just everywhere trying to lick the polish off the fash boots, aren’t you? Are you getting paid for this? It’s difficult to believe someone would have such alarmingly stupid personal opinions and still manage to figure out how to use the internet
- fruitycoder@sh.itjust.worksEnglish24 days
I’m not using their IP publically. I’m training my AI to make fortnight for the browser
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysI am not talking about training the Ai, I am talking about assets. If you use Fortnite IP, then you are infringing and stealing their IP. Like Halo on the browser, where you didn’t have to provide the assets from the rom yourself.
- fruitycoder@sh.itjust.worksEnglish24 days
But that would mean them scrapping all of my code from GitHub to train their AI would be stealing my IP! That can’t be true, right? Their not thieves, right?
Besides that’s not Master Chief TM that’s AI generated Master Chief. Which is … Obviously … Different, and not just IP laundring
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysBesides that’s not Master Chief TM that’s AI generated Master Chief. Which is … Obviously … Different, and not just IP laundring
Doesn’t matter. You can have IP infringement, without using the exact same likeness. It needs to be samy enough, to count as an infringement / theft.
But that would mean them scrapping all of my code from GitHub to train their AI would be stealing my IP! That can’t be true, right? Their not thieves, right?
I’m not talking about training the Ai.
- fruitycoder@sh.itjust.worksEnglish24 days
Right. When they generate code it’s in the same likeness of my code. Is that really stealing?
- tempest@lemmy.caEnglish24 days
But using it privately (for profit) and calling it training data is perfectly fine.
As such that’s all anyone has to say about “their” data. It being used as training data isn’t copyright infringement or IP theft, as they state themselves.
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysI think you mix up these two things. Regardless of Ai, using copyrighted material (without license) is theft.
- tempest@lemmy.caEnglish24 days
No it isn’t theft. It’s copyright infringement, which is decidedly not theft.
These companies used everyone else’s copy written material for “training” but that’s fine because it was only taking that data from everyone. But once someone takes data from them, IP or not, they claim to have been harmed. But don’t claim they’re harming anyone else…somehow.
They’re not paying anyone for their IP, and no one should pay them for their IP. It isn’t a problem for them, so it’s not a problem for anyone else to do it to them.
Do we honestly believe Microsoft doesn’t have ANY IP owned by others in their training data? They’ve managed to completely destroy their own protections, I can’t see how an actually competent Judge could see it any other way. Sure you’ll find corrupt Judges that’ll side with them, but that doesn’t make it correct.
thingsiplay@lemmy.mlEnglish
24 daysNo it isn’t theft. It’s copyright infringement, which is decidedly not theft.
Copyright infringement is theft.
- tempest@lemmy.caEnglish24 days
Show the law then, because theft has requirements that copyright infringement doesn’t accomplish.












