
If you only require mirrors (RAID 1) then BTRFS works fine, but if you need something more and the system has good support for it (e.g. Ubuntu) then ZFS is better IMO. Yes you can use mdraid with BTRFS, but I prefer 1 ZFS over 10 different moving parts.
I use both, choosing which one depending on the conditions.


Both ZFS and BTRFS require having at least 2 copies for healing, however, unlike a standard RAID1 that is oblivious to which of the 2 copies is healthy, the 2 filesystems use CRC checksums to figure out which is corrupt and recover the good one. As long as you have at least 2 copies, they will check the checksum on every read and heal it if corruption is detected. Besides that, you’d schedule a periodic scrub to also check the data that hasn’t been read in a while.
In ZFS you can tell it to keep 2 copies of everything even if you only have 1 drive, which would give you the healing effect, but this obviously halves the drive capacity, and does not save you if that 1 drive dies, hence spreading it on multiple drives is better.
Personally, I find ZFS easier to use than BTRFS, it’s not that complicated once you get the hang of it, plus LLMs can help anyway. It does have many dials that can be tuned, but unless you are trying to optimize it for a specific usecase, the generally recommend setting are fine for most use cases.
It’s not built into the kernel, but server distros (e.g. Ubuntu) build it as a loadable module, which is kept in step with the kernel, so generally no issues there. On distros like Arch it can be really annoying though.
“Slightly lower” is a bit of an understatement, both for ZFS and BTRFS. Those are CoW (Copy on Write) filesystems, so they are much slower to write, which is a traid off for the benefits of CoW. On the other hand, reads are only slightly slower (since CRC is always checked), and thanks to transparent compression, they can be even faster to read.
One downside of ZFS over BTRFS is fragmentation, all CoW filesystems suffer from it, but BTRFS allows you to defragment in place (takes a while though) unlike ZFS.
If you can’t afford storage, the data you want to store is generally compressible, and speed is not critical/priority, it might be woth using ZFS/BTRFS just for the transparent compression to save on space and get more out of the drives you have. I’m using BTRFS on a Fedora system for this reason alone, helps me avoid buying a new SSD 😬