• Too bad it’s a bit too much of a hassle to remove the pancake lenses if you don’t need them.

  • 2 months

    I maintain that it always should have been a streaming-only headset. Without controllers. Everyone seems to agree the older Index controllers are better.

    • 2 months

      VR headsets effectively need to run two 4K displays, one for each eye, and you have all the processing for controller tracking too. You also have eye tracking, they’re doing the whole foveated streaming thing everybody has been gushing over about (it’s really cool tech!). The mobile chip they used is nothing special, it’s a Snapdragon 8 Gen 3, a 3 year old smartphone processor (certainly powerful enough to run lighter PC games, but nothing more than that. It’s kind of insane that a phone can even do that nowadays!)

    • They mention that the compute required to support streaming was also already enough to run standalone games. Removing the ability to run games on the headset wouldn’t have changed the design much anyway.

      • Where do they say this? I don’t know why that much ram and processing and storage would be required for just the streaming and fov stuff.

        • I’ve heard it in a few places, one that comes to mind being an interview with some engineers that PC Gamer did. The RAM was originally half (on par with the Quest 3) but once they realized how much the potential library would expand, they bumped the RAM to 16GB.

          This decision was made pre RAM crisis, of course.

          • The RAM was originally half (on par with the Quest 3)

            If they could reduce the RAM by half and still have a streaming capable rig that’s about $100 off the bill of materials and potentially doubles your manufacturing capability (assuming the bottleneck is RAM acquisition).

            If this is true, why couldn’t Valve just release a Frame Lite in ~6 months that is stream-only?

            • I can’t imagine them doing that. Here’s my reasoning: You can’t make everyone happy. People are already mad that the frame isn’t EXACTLY what they expected it to be.

              So you’re proposing one solution, to appease one group of people. Essentially the same Frame but just half or less a quarter of the RAM? To save a hundred bucks?

              Then what? You’ll have a device that can TECHNICALLY run some games locally, but now it’s underpowered. But people will get confused and try it anyway and be mad. Or they’ll get confused and buy the wrong one.

              They could make it painfully clear that it’s streaming only, and even limit the software so it can’t play locally. But people will hack it and try anyway and probably still complain.

              Or claim that valve is scalping money for the higher ram version.

              Or any other number of problems that involve people not being happy with them. And all of it costs them money to produce the second SKU.

              Maybe they’ll do it if everyone cries loud enough. But in my opinion, it’s smartest to keep one product, with one performance profile to target. Just like the Deck.

              It’s not worth the hassle for them, and it’s not worth saving $100 for me.

              In my opinion.

          • But that would have been in response to non streaming, where the headset handles everything. I’m talking about non streaming.

            Several people around here keep claiming valve said the hardware in it was pretty much the same hardware needed for a streaming only design, but no one has actually been able to provide a source of them saying it, and it sounds like BS in a rumor mill at this point. Especially because it doesn’t make any sense.

            *Edit: See. Silent downvotes and no links of anyone from valve claiming that pretty much these specs were required for a streaming only system.

              • Yes. It affirms that there’s a bunch of fan boys in here that are parroting off what they heard from other fan boys and that there is nothing from valve saying they needed the same spec to make a streaming only system work.

      • 2 months

        How does that even work? You can stream 4k games from a Raspberry Pi. That’s why there’s an entire industry dedicated to exactly that.

        • 2 months

          The point they are getting at is that in order to stream games to a VR headset, that headset needs to have a certain amount of compute power in order to interpret the stream while also handling tracking, connecting to controllers, etc. That amount of compute power is also capable of running games in standalone, so they may as well support that option as well.

          • 2 months

            That makes no sense. It requires more compute to run a whole-ass game along with tracking controllers than it does just tracking controllers.

            • 2 months

              Streaming to a VR headset involves the headset computing more than just controller tracking. It needs to interpret the incoming stream and all sorts of other various things that need to be computed. A VR headset that has a processor that is powerful enough to stream heavy games is also powerful enough to play light games in standalone.

              • 2 months

                Streaming to a VR headset involves the headset computing more than just controller tracking.

                Yes but not much. Again streaming games from weak hardware is a whole industry. It’s the point of platforms like Luna, GeForce Now, Stadia, etc. Streaming from cheap Android TV boxes and such. Valve even sold their own cheap streaming box, the Steam Link.

                • 2 months

                  Yes but not much.

                  Not much, but apparently enough that the minimum requirement is capable of running simpler games locally.

                  platforms like Luna, GeForce Now, Stadia, etc.

                  Streaming foveated VR is more computationally taxing on the client than simply streaming basic pancake games. You can stream Cyberpunk to your Chromecast because it just involves the server sending a video feed to the client and the client sending controller inputs back to the server. Streaming a VR game involves all those same things, but it also involves extra computation on the client side (controller tracking, eye tracking, headset gyro, and other various spatial calculations) that then get sent off to the server along with the controller inputs. That extra computation requires more client-side processing power than is needed for streaming Cyberpunk to your Chromecast.

                • Yeah, the most powerful boxes are on par with the chip in the Steam Frame, aside from RAM and the SSD. The biggest costs are elsewhere. It’s not the chip itself. It’s just one CPU generation ahead of the same CPU series as the Ayn Thor base model.

                  The cost simply wouldn’t go down enough by switching to the lightest CPU

                • Try decoding an AV1 stream from Sunshine without hardware acceleration. It takes a much higher compute performance than you apparently believe.

                • Are you talking about game streaming some AAA ultra graphics Unreal game? Because there are a lot of other games that only take a fraction of compute (an extreme being doom) that take maybe even less compute ressources than trying to stream anything. And streaming can take a lot of compute if you ever looked at hardware stats during a discord stream. that would be especially true for something “surroundHD” like a 3D wirtual vorld where a lot of video gets to be stored or its going to be a pain in the eyes turning the head (and that ping will be too high for foveated streaming)