- blackberry28@sh.itjust.worksEnglish2 months
I’m against military duty as well, but why do those protests always assume that conscripts will get sent into warzones? That’s definitely not the case in germany. Conscripts will never get sent into warzones unless germany gets actively attacked. Those protestors think that if military duty gets reactivated, every conscript gets instantly sent to Ukraine. Ffs, this is Germany, not Russia.
- 2 months
Not only that, in the past, Germany had an excellent system of substitute service for people who opted against serving in the military, with plenty of options to choose from.
- DrunkenPirate@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
I don’t get the arguments of our youth. On one hand they say „I‘m not going to die in war for ya“ and on the other side they say „Putin will not attack us because we have way more weapons“
One has to fight for its rights, it’s not given as a present. If a neighbor country is aggressive and unpredictable, one has to serve in military service or civil service. Same as all young men in Germany did as well.
- for_some_delta@beehaw.orgEnglish2 months
There is “no war, but the class war” because wealthy young men never see combat. Decision makers do not send their own children to die. Putin is also sending the poor.
- DrunkenPirate@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
True. It’s like this for the entire humankind.
Still, standard people nowadays have far more rights and autonomy than in any other time. This was fought by our ancestors in last two centuries. Even the pure possibility to elect a leader, who decides about war, is a pretty new phenomen. If you do not fight for those rights at all needed levels, it will taken away by the wealthy.
- DrunkenPirate@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
I won‘t place hedonistic motifs in the same line as a fight for rights for people.
- DrunkenPirate@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
It’s about your individual being and avoid suffering. Others don’t matter.
- 2 months
autonomous weapons aren’t that far away, and are almost certainly cheaper than veterans
- susieq0044@sh.itjust.worksEnglish2 months
Yes, and you will need people to operate them. Such people are called soldiers.
- alexquiniou@lemmy.zipEnglish2 months
Let’s be honnest with ourself. We are on lemmy. We are commenting from our home confort about something we don’t have to live.
- varyingExpertise@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
Full service mentality. Love to get up in the morning, go to school for free, have all the amenities they are used to and certainly someone else really should do something so they can repeat that day tomorrow.
I served, I am on the reserve list, I am one of the ones that will go and do something if necessary. But no, you go ahead and do you, everything is taken care of, no need to take over any responsibility other than paying your club membership. I mean, taxes, sorry.
- prole@lemmy.blahaj.zoneEnglish2 months
Oh wow, are we sure this is the mentality that we want to see in military personnel towards the people they’re supposed to be protecting? Yikes.
- varyingExpertise@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
that we want to see in military personnel towards the people they’re supposed to be protecting?
I’m not sure where you’re from, but, at least in Germany it wasn’t “the military” and “the rest of the people that they work for”. Because many people had served, at least until 2005/2006-ish, the idea that we all would stand together in case of conflict and a lot of people in civil life would go back temporarily and do their service at the front was much more common.
As I said, this has been widely replaced by a service expectation. Thrown money in the magic military box, get protection, precisely as you’ve said.
- Phoenixz@lemmy.caEnglish2 months
I fuñly agree with them that it shouldn’t be necessary
I also understand how the world is and that currently a tiny few oligarchs and dictators are willing to burn the world to rule over the ashes and unfortunately there is really only one way to stop that
:(
- 2 months
Yes, unfortunately, it’s a necessary evil. The alternatives would be much worse.
- susieq0044@sh.itjust.worksEnglish2 months
That’s naive. Putin is building an army with 1.5 million soldiers, he’s in panic mode and highly unpredictable. The only thing that will stop Russia is strength.
- 2 months
Putin is barely managing against a solo Ukraine and painstakingly avoiding open conflict with NATO territory. If you think Germany will be solo against Russia and thus requires a draft, you’re the naive one
ExLisper@lemmy.curiana.netEnglish
2 monthsPutin is barely managing against a solo Ukraine
Because Ukraine is supported by Europe which for now is beyond the reach of Russia. So Ukraine is successfully striking deep inside Russia but Russia can’t touch the supply chain of Ukraine. Putin obviously is not planning to conquer all Europe. He wants to damage infrastructure crucial to supporting Ukraine and divert NATO’s resources away from Ukraine. He will use as little resource as possible to achieve that, not invade Europe with all he has. He will do it if he sees that Europe is too weak to respond and so far Europe is proving that it clearly is.
painstakingly avoiding open conflict with NATO
[citation needed]
Russia regularly sends in drones into NATO airspace and attacks infrastructure. They tried to blow up planes filled with ammunition on an airport in Germany. I wouldn’t call that “painstakingly avoiding open conflict”. They are testing the boundaries and so far NATO showed that they are willing to tolerate clear acts of war while Russia is getting closer and closer to open conflict.
If you think Germany will be solo against Russia
No one says that. What you’re saying makes no sense. You think that Russia can’t fight entire NATO but also think that Germany is somehow preparing to fight them alone. Germany needs the draft to be able to help its allies. Every NATO ally is trying to improve its military now because when shit hits the fan they will all have to work together.
- Eheran@lemmy.worldEnglish2 months
The problem is not Russia defeating NATO. It is cowards stopping their support for Ukraine to “live in peace”, idiots pressuring their government to stop helping to not get involved. That is the problem. That is what Ukraine is afraid of. And looking at how dumb and selfish most people are, yes, that can absolutely happen.
- CosmoNova@lemmy.worldEnglish2 months
The EU, combined with the UK and Turkey have over 2 million soldiers already, more advanced equipment and vastly more capital.
Also no, Putin isn‘t. He‘s been putting mercenaries of over 40 nations and many Russians into the meat grinder for almost 5 years. Russia has no resources to win any war right now.
- 2 months
Russia has no resources to win any war right now
They’ve got the resources to wage a war, though. “Win” is a relative term.
- CosmoNova@lemmy.worldEnglish2 months
Win is a pretty clear term. If you get less out of a war than you‘re putting in, you lost. If Russia has this much trouble against little Ukraine they would get absolutely steamrolled by Europe.
- wizzor@sopuli.xyzEnglish2 months
Si vis pacem, para bellum.
In Finland we have mandatory conscription. It is a very good way of getting a military, whoch is dofficult to use for expansionist adventures, but very good for defence.
It is not cheap. Putting a million people through the training represents a significant loss of GDP, but imagine trying to attack a country where half the population has even some serious military training.
- stoy@lemmy.zipEnglish2 months
Swede here, I went to muster back in the early 2000s, but my hearing was too bad, and I was failed out.
At the time I was happy, I wasn’t ready for it, but these days I think it would have been a great source of self dicipline for me.
Eh, in either case, from what I have heard/read, mandatory conscription will also boost social cohesion of a population which makes sense.
- 2 months
I think there is value in Finland’s system, when Russia clearly is a huge threat to Europe.
Maybe every part of Europe should have a system like that. Perhaps everybody, rich or poor, and perhaps even older as well as younger (not kids or pensioners though) could be trained to contribute in some way to national defence. This could include training for building weapons in factories for example. Look at how important Ukraine’s weapons companies are currently, when it comes to their national defence.
- 2 months
Every accusation is a confession with fascists, from Ukraine to Israel.
Historically, all conflicts with Russia came from Europe. I don’t see this as anything different.
This is all you need to know about the West’s adversarial nature toward Russia

- 2 months
Ah yes, I remember now, it was Ukraine who forced Putin to invade Crimea in 2014.
/s
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
It is a very good way of getting a military
It is a very effective way of getting a military, allright. But good? No! It’s like “slavery is a very good way to build some pyramids”.
- 2 months
Its not mandatory in the way slavery is, you can choose to do a civilian service instead. I do think there is some good value in having people serve their societies in less voluntary ways, I think the unifying social effects of that alone is really valuable, in this increasingly individualistic age we live in
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
Cool, I can “chose” to which kind of labor I am forced (but only whether the labor is done with or without a weapon in my hands).
Crazy, I know, but you can train solidarity in a society in other ways than forcing people to work (or train them to kill and be killed).
- varyingExpertise@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
in other ways than forcing people to work
Great, show me the country that has a working, sustainable implementation of that. The share of people that will take out more from any kind of society than they put in is too large for any group to work without at least some pressure to enforce that equilibrium.
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
Yep. That is what people always said towards societal change
- Abolishing slavery won’t work, who would do the work?
- Health insurance cannot work
- Social security cannot work
- Automation will not work, everybody is going to starve
- …
You know, the state has crazy influence on its citizen. Where? In school. But the whole educational system is not build on community, solidarity and compassion. It’s build on competition. And when you finish some 9-13 years of competition, is it strange that you end up looking for your own advantage? I doubt it. And that kind of education is eradicated magically if we then force people to rob through mud one year and further teach them how to kill? Yep, that’ll work 😅
- 2 months
My friend who did the civil service spent a few weeks at a camp learning about first aid, fire safety among other emergency skills. Then the rest of the year they just worked at an art school (because they was allowed to choose where they work at) updating computers and hanging around with youths. Yea, the pay wasn’t amazing but it was experience none the less, and I am really glad to live in a country where regular people have at least some readiness to help and keep the society running during wartime or any other massive crisis. This system isn’t due to authoritarian governmental malevolence, its to prepare us all for a war that is unfortunately a possibility due to our neighbour.
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
I know a guy for whom it was A-OK, that’s why forced labor for everyone is a good thing
Ok. I was a conscript, I’d say it was Ok for me as well, doesn’t make it right.
Reminds me of the one heir of Germany’s Balsen dynasty. She made some headlines some time ago saying something like “Forced labor during WW2 in our company was not too bad. We paid the workers and, as far as I know, treated them well.”
- 2 months
I mean of course we wouldn’t have this system in a better world, but that is just what living next to russia demands. For me the trade off of 0.5 - 1 year of service in exchange for societal safety is worth the temporary lack of freedom.
- 2 months
- susieq0044@sh.itjust.worksEnglish2 months
I like your example, as the pyramids weren’t built by slaves.
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months

But, Ackchyually, ackchyually, slaves built shit in Ancient Egypt, they even had “conscripts” (funnily enough called explicitly forced labor in the Wiki article). So, all good, we pay our forced laborers some token amount, which they can’t even negotiate, and then it’s fine! Guess who used that argument to whitewash forced labor? You wouldn’t believe it.
Anyways, to concede to your historical accuracy, I’ll rephrase:
It is a very effective way of getting a military, allright. But good? No! It’s like “slavery is a very good way to produce cotton”.
Because my sentiment was about the correctness of the result of forced labor, not about the forced labor itself 🙄.
- 2 months
JFC, it was a joke metaphor.
Replace it with Holocaust slaves. This IS GERMANY.
- wizzor@sopuli.xyzEnglish2 months
The conscription military only works when people feel their country is worth defending. There are plenty of people who declined to serve for moral reasons. There are plenty of reasons to criticize the system (gender equality rises to mind).
I think part of the reason the Finnish political system serves the people more than some others is because it needs to. We have our problems of course, a lot of the population is old, so prioritizing young people doesn’t always happen the way it ought to. Still, most people are OK with going, very few support abolishing the system because we know we all are needed to make attacking us fucking suck.
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
What I never understand about this reasoning…when “most” people feel this way, why is it compulsory and needs fines? If everybody and their grandma is happy defending the country, they could go voluntarily. Who cares about the threefiddy people who don’t go? They would be shitty comrades in the trenches anyway. So, why are people forced, then?
- 2 months
What I never understand about this reasoning…when “most” people feel this way, why is it compulsory and needs fines?
Well, what are you doing to give back to society, apart from posting on Lemmy about every form of compulsion being slavery?
People increasingly treat society and the state as a giant free-for-all where everything has to be provided by an abstract entity rather than a community where you participate.
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
Well, what are you doing to give back to society
😅👍
For once, I served as conscript. Even did three months extra. Funnily enough that is not so much what I consider my most interesting contribution to society.
“Community” and “participation” are the keywords here. I feel like being bullied to do something is not very “participate in something”. It’s just being bullied.
- wizzor@sopuli.xyzEnglish2 months
Tragedy of the commons, no individual downside encourages freeriding.
- 2 months
- Lena@sopuli.xyzEnglish2 months
Good. Slavery, forced work and stripping people off bodily autonomy is not a European value, and people who are forcing authoritarianism down our throats are no different than Putin supporters. I will fight for values, not for the flag and a song, and if Europe loses its course, its no longer worth defending.
- disco_tin@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
People who call military service “slavery” are in the same category as those who say “taxes are theft”.
- varyingExpertise@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
So, assume the Ukranian people had all followed that principle. What would their daily lives look like now?
- Lena@sopuli.xyzEnglish2 months
Well, all the men (like half a million of them?) who were involuntarily conscripted, kidnapped from their homes, tortured to comply and killed in action would prefer to be alive.
- varyingExpertise@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
Alright. So in principle, the whole world should bow to the one head of state that is bound to exist somewhere that does not subscribe to these high ideals. Got it.
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
But…not forcing men to fight, doesn’t mean that there’s no army? I’m confused.
But anyway, if your country is attacked, but nobody (or too few) want to defend it voluntarily…maybe, that is kind of a vote with the feet, that either your odds are very bad anyways or that people rather chose to live in occupation and deem it less bad than fighting and dying ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- Bruuder@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
You say you are fighting for values, but if you’re not fighting for the nation or the union of nations that represent those values, it’s just empty rhetoric
- electric_nan@lemmy.mlEnglish2 months
What values? Genuinely. Which nation or union of nations is upholding good values? Germany? If you protest against genocide there, you will be beaten and jailed by the same government that wants to send you to die in Russia (again).
- kossa@feddit.orgEnglish2 months
It’s a conundrum, isn’t it? If one of my values is “people should not be involuntarily drafted into the army”, what to do then?







